Flamme Rouge: A Review by Eric Booth

Flamme Rouge

img_0114

Designed by Asger Sams Granerud

Published by Lautapelit.fi 

Art by Ossi Hiekkala, Jere Kasanen(You should check them you on BGG as the art in Flamme Rouge is excellent. I love the 1920s feel of the images.)

You can listen to Eric’s thoughts on Week 100 of the WDYPTW Podcast at the 21:47 mark.

Flamme Rouge, AKA Red Flag, is quick bicycle racing game that takes place in the last kilometer of a race. You will be controlling 2 riders, a Roller and a Sprinter. How you control your riders is done through a clever play of cards. Each rider has their own deck of cards and you will draw 4 cards from one rider and pick one card to play and the ones you didn’t pick are returned to the bottom of the deck face up. (Recycling) them. Then you do the same for the other rider. This choice has to be done one rider at a time. So you are gambling on what cards you might draw for your other rider. Each card has a number on it which will determine how far along the track that rider can travel. You’ll be wanting to try and keep your Roller out in front of your Sprinter to soak up the exhaustion cards you will inevitably be getting throughout the race. Then when you are getting close to the finish line your Roller will be full of exhaustion cards and this is when your Sprinter should start using his big cards to, well, sprint to the finish. It’s a very clever mechanic that is very thematic to how actual bike races work. You have the team pulling (Slipstreaming) the sprinter along then they move out of the way for that last push at the end of the race by your Sprinter.

img_0117

Now that you know how the cards work, let’s move on to how the movement works. After each player selects which cards they are going to play for each of their riders, all players will reveal them simultaneously. Then in rider order each player will move their rider along the track. A rider can pass through other riders but can’t stop their movement on another rider unless there is a free lane next to that rider. If there is no free lane the rider is placed behind the rider they would have landed on. Which can actually be a good thing as it could save your rider from getting an exhaustion card. This is repeated until all the riders have been moved. After this is done the Slip-streaming phase happens. You start at the back of the pack and you’ll look at each pack of riders, which can consist of only one rider, and see if there is no more than one square between them and the next pack of riders. If there is only one square between them you will move the riders up to the next pack of riders creating an even bigger pack. You will continue to do this until you have closed up all the one square gaps between the riders thus creating one huge pack of riders. If there are more than one square between the packs they are considered to be out of the slip-stream and will not be moved up to the next pack. Oh and there’s optional hills that can be added to the track that add another whole dimension to the race depending on whether you’re going up hill or down hill. There are some more movement subtleties that I’m not going to go over here but they are very easy to learn.

img_0128

Now it’s time deal out those dreaded exhaustion cards. These are the cards that will gum up your deck with that puny little 2 speed card. Why is this so important and painful you might ask? It’s because the cards you picked to move your riders earlier are removed from the game so they’re out of play forever. So in a weird way this is almost a deck building game, sorta, but your deck just keeps getting worse as the race goes on. So you need to be very tactical on what cards you play and when to play them. How your riders get exhaustion cards is determined by whether or not they have an empty square in front of them on the track after the slip-streaming phase is done. This exhaustion card is added face up to bottom of that rider’s deck to show it’s ugly face later on in the race
This pretty much sums up the game. Very simple with some very important decisions to be made in order to crosse finish line first. Oh yeah did I mention that the person who crosses the finish line first isn’t necessarily the winner? It’s the rider who goes furthest past the finish line that wins. Now let’s find out what I think of Flamme Rouge.

img_0121

Likes:

  • What do I like about Flamme Rouge? Almost all of it as a matter of fact.
  • The simplicity of the game play along with the tough decisions on which cards to play and when to play those cards. Flamme Rouge doesn’t get bogged down with overly complicated, needless rules. In fact the rules for the game are only 4 pages long and 1 of those pages is an overview of the game components.
  • There’s no tokens to keep track of. No dice to be rolled. It’s all down to when you play your cards.
  • I feel Flamme Rouge could be an excellent gateway game to new gamers or your non gamer friends. I know this is thrown around a lot but I really believe it with this game.
  • The game is very scale-able between whether you want an easier track to a more difficult track by removing or adding the hill tracks to the game to accommodate who you are playing with.
  • As for the components? They are top notch. Super thick cardboard for the player boards and the track. Highly detailed miniatures for the two different riders which leads me to the one thing that will be in my Dislikes column.

img_0135

Dislikes:

  • Now what did I dislike about the game? Sometimes if can be very hard to distinguish between which rider is the Sprinter and which rider is the Roller. There is a little itty bitty S on the back of the Sprinter and an itty bitty R on the back of the Roller but they don’t stand out at all. This can lead to some confusion sometimes on whether you are picking a card for the correct rider or not. And this is truly a very minor thing. After a few plays you will just be able to tell them apart easily.

So in conclusion, I’ve really enjoyed every play of Flamme Rouge so far. And, from what I could tell, so did everyone else who played it with me. The simplicity of the game play is what I would call it’s greatest strength. So, if you’re able to get a copy and you’re a fan of racing games then I would highly recommend Flamme Rouge to you.

img_0134

Haspelknecht

Haspelknecht

Designed by Thomas Spitzer

Published by Capstone Games

Art by Johannes Sich at Jojosich.de

A Review by Eric Booth – @EricBooth

You can hear Eric’s Review of Haspelknecht at the 44:49 mark on Week 99 of the What Did You Play This Week Podcast.

 

30043563492_b940707e79_o
In Haspelknecht you are taking on the role of a 16th century farmer who, according to the rules, accidentally discovers coal on the surface of his farm. During the game you will be battling the ever present pit water that keeps seeping into your pinge, surface mine, and your actual coal mine shaft, preventing you from removing or mining that precious dusty, black gold. You will be acquiring new developments that will give you a one time benefit or some excellent end game scoring. Or these developments can be extra buildings you can add to your farm to make your mining endeavors more efficient. When you start the game you’ll only start out with a Farmer, Farmhand and a Digger.

30144133701_57b2c2f28d_o

This leads to what I think is the heart of Haspelknecht, the action selection draft. There are 3 colored action discs in the game. Brown, Yellow and Black. You will be drafting these discs in two rounds and these will dictate what your workers will be able to do during the action selection phase. With the Yellow discs you can acquire much needed food. With the Brown discs you can acquire the much needed wood to build the supports in your pinge and later in the mine shaft itself. The placement of this wood will dictate where you will be able to dig out the coal. Then there is the Black discs that will let your workers either remove water from the pinge or to actually mine that precious coal. Now how does this work you say? Well let me tell you.

During the 1st round of drafting discs you will pick one of the Action Pools and pick one of colors of the discs and remove all of those discs and place them on the wheelbarrow labeled with a 1 on your player board. The disc you place on the wheelbarrow labeled 1 will dictate player order for the rest of the season, after the action drafting phase. During the second round you will pick one of the Action Pools and pick a color and take those disc and place them on the wheelbarrow labeled with a 2 on your player board to a maximum of 5 total discs unless you were able to get more than 5 discs on the 1st round of the draft. After figuring out the player order you will move onto the action selection phase. This will be when you get allocate all those wonderful discs you just received during the drafting phase.

30267653745_905f5c9132_o

Now let’s talk about your initial workers. You have the digger that can only remove coal and pit water from your pinge. And this guy thinks a lot of himself as he requires either one yellow disc or one food or one Thaler to do his job. Where as the Farmer and Farmhand can use any of the discs you’ve acquired earlier. There’s a few rules to placing disc onto workers. You can only place like colors on Farmhand and the Farmer to complete tasks with one exception. The Farmer is also able to acquire developments which use various combinations of discs. So if you’re going to use the Development task of your Farmer you place the needed colors required by the development you want on the Farmer. When you’re done allocating your discs, in turn order, you will take the actions in whatever order you want by removing those disc from your workers and returning them to the bag to be drawn later to fill the action selection pools.

29599423254_56491ab202_o

OK, I think I’ve talked that action thing into the ground. Let’s move on to what happens when you’ve removed all the easy to access coal on the surface in your pinge. Well this is where the namesake of the game, Haspelknecht, comes into play. As soon as you remove all the coal from your pinge you will move any pit water you have into the mine shaft. You will retire the bedraggled digger and bring in your miner and the hard to pronounce Haspelknecht. Now these two guys are just as greedy as the digger was, but more efficient. What can they do for you, you might be asking? Well, the Haspelknecht removes both coal and pit water, in fact he is the ONLY person who can remove pit water from the mine shaft. But he requires one of these 3 things. Either a yellow disc, a food, or a thaler. And the miner is even more proud of himself. He requires a food or a thaler but he is able to mine up to 3 coal from the mine into the mine shaft to be later removed by the Haspelknecht. Now your other two available workers are still able to mine coal but they are less efficient in doing it. And remember they are no longer able to remove any water from the mine shaft. That is a job for your Haspelknecht.

29970905230_507f34ac61_o

Wow that was all a mouthful. Now onto the developments. I’m not going to go into all the available developments you can get. But I would like to do a quick rules clarification how you can place your token on a development, as the rule book is just a tad confusing on how this is done. On the first row you can place anywhere regardless of adjacency. On any other row you have to place adjacent to one of your other claimed developments unless you are placing one of your tokens onto a development that an opponent has already claimed. You do not need to be adjacent to one of your other discs to do this but you will have to pay the person who was the last to claim that development a fee. That fee differs with each subsequent row. Doing this will extend your adjacency requirements for later developments. Now all this craziness you have to do has to all be done over 4 seasons and 3 years with the winter season being the coal scoring, pay the government, store you stuff, season.

30152123352_bd467d2d36_o

Enough rambling let’s move onto what I think of the game.

Likes:

  • Haspelknecht gives me that same feeling I get when I play that wonderful game Orleans. What I mean by that is every round you just get the feeling that you’re doing something amazing but just short of what you need to accomplish everything you want to do and I love that in games.
  • I really like how Haspelknecht truly gives you several different paths to victory and that was shown to be true in our last 4 player game. It was a very tight game and each of us went on several different paths during the game. One player was still in the running and did very little actual mining.
  • I’ve played with all player counts and it played great at all player counts. The game scales very very well.
  • The components are all top notch. Nice thick cardboard. No flimsy card stock. Cough, Terraforming Mars, cough cough.

Dislikes:

  • Now what did I dislike about the game? There’s a few confusing places in the rule book like the placement rules on the developments.
  • Some of the icons for the end game scoring are very small and can be hard to read.
  • The only other thing I can think of is that the Action Disc Selection phase can be a little ap inducing. You are trying to see exactly what discs you can take to accomplish what you want to do this round and seeing what discs will be available the next round. Me, I just pretty much ignored the discs in the reserve pool for the most part.

booth-haspelknecht-3

In conclusion, I really like Haspelknecht. If you like what is lovingly called, point salad, many paths to victory, type games then this just might be a game for you. Now know that I didn’t cover everything you can do but I hope enough that you a good idea of what you can do during the game.

booth-haspelknecht-2I give Haspelknecht Two black lung thumbs up.